Jim Daly

Daly Focus Blog

FOTF logo
  • Home
  • Family & Home
  • Current Events
  • Focus News
  • About

An Excess of Democracy?

Life is beginning to return to normal in the Daly house following Tuesday’s historic election.

By “normal” I mean it’s been three days since our home phone rang five times during dinner with candidate robo-calls and our mailbox was overstuffed with campaign flyers!democracy1.jpg

The pundits will continue to analyze Tuesday’s results and draw their subjective conclusions.  I have mine; you have yours.  At a Wednesday press conference, President Obama qualified the outcome as a “shellacking” – a candid admission by any measure. In an interview with CBS’s 60 Minutes, set to air this Sunday, the President was a bit more cautious in his assessment. He said the results, at least from his perspective, were a reflection of poor communication skills as opposed to poorly crafted legislation.

That seems rather generous to me, but I’m curious what you think.

Everyone is entitled to their opinion, of course, but perhaps the oddest response to the election came from today’s edition of the Washington Post. Responding to Iowa voters’ decision to oust three judges who had previously ruled in favor of same-sex marriage, the Post said the outcome represented “an excess of democracy.”

Did you catch that?

An excess of democracy.iowajudges.jpg

The negative retention bids of those Iowa Supreme Court justices is significant. In fact, it is yet another confirmation that the same-sex marriage debate is far from over and the majority of Americans agree with what we have always stood for; when the people speak, they speak for marriage.

The gentleman who led the recall campaign, Bob Vander Platts, had little doubt of the constitutionality and wisdom of their cause.

“I think it will send a message across the country that the power resides with the people. It’s we the people, not we the courts.”

Critics have suggested the outcome is a blow to the independence of the judiciary. Erwin Chermerinsky is the dean of the University of California, Irvine, School of Law. He called it “disturbing” and warned that it might cause judges to be reluctant to protect minorities.

My colleague at CitizenLink, lawyer Bruce Hausknecht, foresaw this precise reaction. Writing the morning after the election, Bruce noted:

Last night’s results in the Iowa retention election will reverberate across the legal and judicial spectrum. Liberals will disingenuously decry the “chilling effect” of this vote on so-called “judicial independence” of judges. “Judicial independence,” we have learned through painful experience, is simply a high-sounding term for the lack of accountability that has enabled the current plague of judicial activism. After this vote, judges will (and surely ought to) think long and hard about the wisdom of creating new “rights” out of thin air.

The Iowa vote encourages us that “we the people” still matter; that the heart of our constitutional system still beats in the citizenry, rather than in the judiciary.

I am no lawyer, but I am a voter who strongly believes in an orthodox understanding of good old-fashioned checks and balances, and in the importance of protecting the institution of marriage and the family. If you ask me, Tuesday’s vote was a positive, not an excessive, expression of democracy.

Sign up for my weekly e-newsletter

Topics: Current Events Tags: events, faith, policy, pop culture November 5, 2010 by Jim Daly with Paul Batura

Related Posts

  • Trusting God That Hope Is on the Way
  • TriumphantAccepting My True Identity in Christ
  • Happiness is No Accident

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Jim-Daly President of Focus on the Family
Jim Daly
with Paul Batura

Posts by Jim

Unhappy couple

Misunderstanding in Marriage

My Passion for the Harvest

Do You Believe in Miracles?

Topics

  • Current Events
  • Family and Home
  • Focus Events
  • Uncategorized

Daly Focus

Jim-Daly Jim Daly is a husband, father and President of Focus on the Family and host of its National Radio Hall of Fame broadcast. His blog, Daly Focus, is full of timely commentary and wisdom designed to help you navigate and understand today’s culture. His latest book is Marriage Done Right.

Jim Daly Blog

Home
About
Posting Guidelines
Terms & Conditions
Privacy Policy
FAQs

Connect with Me

Facebook
Twitter
YouTube
RSS